To
quote the report of the mission carried out by ICOMOS expert Jorge
Gazaneo (1992), " No Philippine church is a complete example of one art
period, but a living document of how time and context have left traces
on the early founding intentions of the original designer builder . . .
at the crossroads of different cultures, Malay, Chinese, European,
American. The architecture and art of The Philippines should be valued
on standards different from those developed by European scholars ".
These churches are architecture built in response to local natural and climatic conditions by Filipino and Chinese craftsmen with no knowledge of European architecture. The men of God who commissioned them reinterpreted the European Baroque to establish a peripheral Baroque which is deceptively western in appearance but wholly Filipino in spirit and context.
The architecture of The Philippines archipelago is a unique one and comparative analysis can only be internal. The dating and settings of the four churches selected for the nomination represent a good sample of the development of this style over some 150 years.
The state of conservation of the churches at Miag ao and Paoay gives cause for concern about their long term future. No evidence was supplied in the nomination dossiers of the exact extent of each site nor of any buffer zone. However, the Philippines authorities subsequently provided details of adequate protective zones around the Churches of Nuestra Sefiora de la Asuncion, San Agustin Paoay, and San Tomas de Villanueva. In the case of San Agustin protection is afforded by its situation within the Preservation Zone of Intramuros.
This group of churches established a style of building and design that was adapted to the physical conditions in the Philippines and had an important influence on later church architecture in the region. The Baroque churches of The Philippines represent the fusion of European church design and construction with local materials and decorative motifs to form a new church building tradition.
These churches are architecture built in response to local natural and climatic conditions by Filipino and Chinese craftsmen with no knowledge of European architecture. The men of God who commissioned them reinterpreted the European Baroque to establish a peripheral Baroque which is deceptively western in appearance but wholly Filipino in spirit and context.
The architecture of The Philippines archipelago is a unique one and comparative analysis can only be internal. The dating and settings of the four churches selected for the nomination represent a good sample of the development of this style over some 150 years.
The state of conservation of the churches at Miag ao and Paoay gives cause for concern about their long term future. No evidence was supplied in the nomination dossiers of the exact extent of each site nor of any buffer zone. However, the Philippines authorities subsequently provided details of adequate protective zones around the Churches of Nuestra Sefiora de la Asuncion, San Agustin Paoay, and San Tomas de Villanueva. In the case of San Agustin protection is afforded by its situation within the Preservation Zone of Intramuros.
This group of churches established a style of building and design that was adapted to the physical conditions in the Philippines and had an important influence on later church architecture in the region. The Baroque churches of The Philippines represent the fusion of European church design and construction with local materials and decorative motifs to form a new church building tradition.